Glutton For Punishment

In this week’s Gospel passages, Jesus encounters Pharisees, very smart, learned men who put lots of emphasis on religious rituals, rules, and regulations.  Because of their intellect and devotedness, some were high priests, members of the Jewish magisterium and Sanhedrin, and those who wanted Jesus silenced and, ultimately, killed.  Though knowledgeable (a human trait), they lacked wisdom (a divine gift), and, though pious, they did not transform their faith to make life better for others.  Jesus referred to them as blind guides, hypocrites, and a brood of vipers.  Though they knew a lot about God, scripture, and religion, they did not know God, nor did they recognize Him when He stood in their midst.  From their attacks, Jesus did not back down.  You might say, He was a glutton for punishment.

Through some of my writings, homilies, and presentations, I have ruffled some feathers by commenting on ecclesial issues like clericalism, national news topics like refusing communion to President Biden, and political mindsets like hatred of former-President Trump.  My attempt is to present the attitude of Christ which, by accounts, is to challenge clerical or pharisaical ways, welcome imperfect people to the table of fellowship, and forgive enemies by showing mercy to those who sin—or those we simply don’t like.  After all, we are all sinners.  Though Jesus said to those He healed, “Go and sin no more,” He realizes our flawed nature.  He infuses our human proclivity of sin and our desire to do better with a divine grace to imitate Him, or as the thirteenth century prayer made famous by the rock opera Godspell states: “see him more clearly, love him more dearly, and follow him more nearly.” 

Having received some rather vicious insults, someone said to me: “People on the extremes, ten percent on either side, are unreasonable, illogical, and cruel.  Don’t engage them unless you’re really a glutton for punishment.”  I recall a former bishop of our Kansas City-Saint Joseph Diocese, Raymond Boland, who was viewed by some as a middle of the road centrist; he joked that if you stand in the middle of the road, you’re likely to get hit by those coming from either direction.  I guess that’s where I stand, too, though I get accused by some of being on the right and others as being left.  Perhaps, I am naïve in thinking that most people will dialogue about important matters rather than remain entrenched in a particular way of thinking.  At the turn of the century, the same bishop warned that polarization may be the greatest destructive force we will face, what he prophetically described then as a dirty twelve-letter word. 

The former Jesuit superior, Pedro Arrupe, was criticized for his tremendous optimism; even when one of his most heartfelt decisions was reversed by the Vatican, he reiterated his conviction that God can and will do what is best.  I desire a dose of his optimism, even if it makes me seem naive.  I hold onto a hope that those on opposite sides can come together in open, honest, and loving dialogue; and I’d like to keep working at it, even if it means taking some hits, even if it means that I’m a glutton for punishment.

5 thoughts on “Glutton For Punishment

  1. Dear Father, I do not think it’s political to deny Pelosi Eucharist. She is in a very public office saying she’s a good Catholic while pushing an anti Catholic view on abortion. If I were to go to confession saying I believed every women had the right to kill her unborn baby & I would help pass laws for us to pay for this I would hope absolution would be withheld.

    Sent from my iPhone



  2. Father thank you for your words of wisdom. Some people get stuck on one issue, I guess people that believe in the death penalty or against helping the poor or those In need shouldn’t get communion either? I have never heard any politician push abortion. No one is pro abortion. the belief is pro choice. The choice to be made by the people involved.
    You father are one of the only reason I have not left the Catholic Church running. I just keep thinking #wwjd what would Jesus do. Preach love and acceptance of all.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. You characterize your writings as commentary. They seem to be critical, and not complimentary. We are inundated with negativity, we yearn for positivity.

    Sent from my iPad



  4. Father,
    I look forward each week to your blog! It has frequently left me with hope, compassion and positivity. I am truly befuddled how that can be perceived as anything but spreading the word of God! You have inspired me and I have frequently shared your thoughtful insights with others!
    Thank you again for your optimism and your continued pursuit of doing God’s work!
    Mary Duffy


  5. Chat and I love your weekly blogs. It is our belief system and we so appreciate your thoughts.

    Sent from my iPhone



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.